Recent comments in /f/personalfinance

Schiendelman t1_jef0rra wrote

Reply to comment by kkiran in Is a $500 car payment too much by [deleted]

That’s a whole lot of assumptions.

If you care about your health, it’s definitely better to bike. If you care about your time, combining your commute with your cardio is hard to beat.

$6000 a year is an awful lot to give up, especially considering the total cost of car ownership is another couple hundred a month on top of that, and more in my area, where a parking spot is $200 a month or more.

As you make more money, you start to get flexibility - you can reasonably do things like spending that additional money for a house near a train, where you don’t need a car. Then that $500 is an investment rather than depreciation. Rather than penny pinching, it’s strategy that can pay dividends for the rest of your life.

1

VW84GTI t1_jef07b6 wrote

OP, a relevant data point that is missing is if you have reliable transportation right now? If you do not have reliable transportation, you need that and cannot wait on a car.

Again, at your age and assuming you’re not tied down by a wife and kids, I’m going to say you need to get a side job to pay this car off as fast as you possibly can. Reliable transportation is critical to getting promoted, anxiety, etc.

If you’re going to commit to this car deal, at this interest rate, you need to dedicate all your free resources to paying it off. The reason is you’re basically putting the car on a credit card. (My credit cards have been under 13% all of my adult life (excluding rewards cards)). Paying it off aggressively as possible will help counteract that ridiculous interest rate, making it irrelevant.

1

Rave-Unicorn-Votive t1_jef026f wrote

It's probably a better question to ask if 30% is realistic for a V/HCOL area. It's usually not and 40% isn't uncommon at all.

If the delta between base and total comp is 100% discretionary, I'd use the base for calculation purposes. But 35% of base on rent isn't financially reckless either.

4

t-poke t1_jeezhdr wrote

> Okay, well I could pay my $400 one off right now

Then pay it off. You're paying 30% interest on it, that's insane. There's no excuse for not paying it off if you have the money for it.

> I'm not really understanding why people think I shouldn't?

Because, if you want an honest answer, your posts here show you do not know how to responsibly handle a credit card and the last thing you should do is give yourself the ability to pile up even more high interest debt.

Use the ones you have responsibly (which means never paying one single penny of interest) for awhile. Then get a new card once you know you can handle the ones you have. Because right now, you can't handle them.

3

Select_Werewolf2328 t1_jeeys3h wrote

I'm going to be blunt (sorry), but you need to sell the collections to help you minimize this new rough part of your life. Debt can crush you. You also shouldn't have two cards with all that debt. You are young, find a second job. Pay everything off. Those interest rates are no joke. You can do this. Fix it now before it gets worse.

4

HomiesTrismegistus t1_jeeykxx wrote

Okay, well I could pay my $400 one off right now. I just figured I'd make payments instead. I just want to make sure that I have a higher limit, I'm not really understanding why people think I shouldn't? I really just want to get rid of these two and have a card with a higher limit, even if that means just paying off my $400 one.

0